Reckless in Kashmir

The new crop of young Kashmiris think nothing of facing teargas shells or bullets. With them around, New Delhi needs to be worried. Extremely so
Srinagar
Hit on the head. And he is not alone. There are many youngsters like him. Some with degrees in business administration and computer applications. They’re all part of the stone pelting protests, and are undeterred by injuries. (Photo: RAHUL PANDITA)
They aren’t stone pelters for hire. After the day’s over, they get busy loading the day’s events on Facebook. (Photos: ASHISH SHARMA)
This policeman with ‘Sexy Ayoub’ scrawled on his shield says his eyes have grown accustomed to teargas smoke now.
Owais, an 18-year-old protestor, lies on a hospital bed, weak and unable to speak. His family says he couldn’t bear not to protest.

The boys are in hiding. The police are active, raiding their houses. But the boys are away, staying with this relative or that. Mobile phones have been put away, even their batteries removed. But at the end of each day, fresh pictures and video clips mostly posted under fake identities make their way to Facebook: of them pelting stones; flashing victory signs, their faces masked; climbing police gypsies; running away and jumping into Srinagar’s Dal Lake. 

And they don’t do it for money, they say. Not even for fun. But to protest against the “occupation of our land”. These are the new-generation protestors of Kashmir: English-speaking, Nike-wearing boys, fans of Bob Dylan, at the forefront of the recent agitation here. They have degrees in business administration, computer applications and the like. Some of them are still in college. Aged 17 to 21, they are already veterans in engaging Indian security forces in the Valley. They have seen their friends dying in front of their eyes. They have received bullet injuries themselves, or have been hit by rubber bullets and teargas shells, many times over in some cases. Some have been arrested under the stringent Public Safety Act. But nothing deters them. 

Go back a day before: in downtown Srinagar, 20-year-old Irfan (name changed) takes out a Palestinian scarf and secures it around his face. It has four holes, for eyes, his nose and mouth. It is the day that separatist leader Mirwaiz Umar Farooq has been granted permission to hold a protest rally on the condition that there be no violence. On a hot afternoon, thousands of men, women and children have gathered outside Jama Masjid, Srinagar.

The crowd, swelling by the minute, chants slogans in unison, slogans that range from ‘death to India’ to ‘freedom for Kashmir’. In between, somebody remembers the ‘martyrs’ too—mostly boys like Irfan—who have died over the past month in police firing. 

The Mirwaiz emerges, and the march begins. On the way, masked men pop out of the procession and make vehement requests, asking onlookers to join. Most of them do. Some people are content to peep out of the windows of their houses, recording the scenario on their mobile phones. A few in the crowd sprinkle water on the rest for some relief from the heat. Drinking water tinged with orange squash is being served to protestors. Women sing wanwun, traditional Kashmiri songs that hail the fallen men as bridegrooms of azaadi, of ‘freedom’. 

Irfan is part of this protest. His shoes that he says he bought recently at a suburban Delhi shopping mall are already worn out, thanks to the constant cat-and-mouse game he plays with security personnel. He is not some school dropout. He has a bachelor’s degree in computer applications, and uses his Sony Ericsson phone to capture images of stone pelting that he later uploads on Facebook. One of his friends recently used his PhotoShop software skills to digitally replace Mahatma Gandhi’s photo on a Rs 1,000 note with that of Kashmiri separatist leader Syed Ali Shah Geelani. It is a hit on various social networking sites.

Handling the crowd is another young man who calls himself Masood Wafai. He has a business in Russia, and has arrived in Kashmir a week ago. “We are under occupation,” he grimly says, “And I have not come here at the invitation of somebody, to earn Rs 150 for pelting stones, as the State accuses us of. I have left a business to take part in the protests.” 

At a market square, the Mirwaiz alights from his Scorpio SUV and tries addressing the crowd with the aid of a tiny loudspeaker that proves to be inept for the job. In five minutes, he is gone, rushing back in his vehicle with bodyguards to offer prayers at Srinagar’s lakeside Hazratbal shrine. “This is a signal that the crowd can now do whatever it wishes to,” whispers a local journalist. The crowd follows on foot. A few get tired and take rides on a few passing motorcycles. 

En route, at the Kashmir University gate, the police and CRPF are waiting for them. The road has been sealed with barbed wire. Led by a young deputy superintendent of police, the cops’ contingent approaches the crowd with a stern warning, advising the protestors to abort the march. There is a ruffle through the crowd, and a debate ensues for about ten minutes. Behind barbed wire, boys from a neighbouring locality come out of their homes, ignoring the curfew, to raise slogans. On hearing their cries, the main crowd of protestors is emboldened to raise its ante. In the police contingent, a policeman with ‘Sexy Ayoub’ scrawled on his shield caresses his teargas gun. A police Gypsy blurts to life with warnings for those who have just emerged from their houses. “Go back,” they are told. 

As they do so, a young man comes to me and extends his hand. “Hi, I am Kamal Khan (name changed),” he introduces himself. I recognise him. Back in Delhi, Kamal had been sending me pictures and links of stories on my Facebook account about the killing of protestors. ‘So many people have been killed, shame to Indian democracy,’ he would write. Before leaving for Kashmir, I had sent him a message saying that I would like to meet him. ‘Send me a message on Facebook and I’ll get in touch myself,’ he wrote back, ‘The internet is being monitored by the police.’ And now, by sheer coincidence, the crowd of protestors had ended up outside his house—and he spotted my face. 

Kamal has an MBA degree. He takes out a cigarette, lights it, and speaks about “oppression of Kashmiris” in the same breath. “For us there is no difference between the local police and the CRPF,” he says, “They are both an organ of the Indian State, out in Kashmir to repress the genuine sentiments of people.” 

That moment, the negotiations taking place behind us snap off, and the cops charge the crowd with laathis and teargas shells. A police Gypsy takes a turn to roar its way against the boys on the other side of the barbed wire. Kamal and I run away. In any such melee, the police does not distinguish between protestors and journalists. In the past few weeks, many journalists have been beaten up severely while covering similar protests. Kamal turns into a street and I turn into another. A hand pulls me into a house, and the door slams shut. A boy looks at me, smiles and says, “Bachh gaye!” I am offered water and an invitation to the attic, from where the action on the road is visible. 

After a few minutes, I go back out—to see a boy rushing towards the university gate. He has been hit by a stone and his head is bleeding. There is teargas smoke all around. A magistrate is standing at the gate, watching the sequence of events. “I don’t know when this will end,” he says. 

A man passes by in shabby clothes. The magistrate tries to stop him. “Ashfaq, it is me,” he says. The man looks at him blankly, mumbles something and just runs away. “Allah! Can you imagine, this man is a PhD, and now I don’t know what has happened to him,” says the magistrate, amid the noise. Teargas shells are still being fired. At the end of the road, Sexy Ayoub stands smoking a cigarette. “This teargas smoke doesn’t bother me any longer. Even my tears have dried up,” he says, staring at a motorcycle that fell down in the commotion. A little later, the police party makes another big appearance. The protestors have been chased away. A CRPF soldier walks past the fallen motorcycle and smashes its rear-view mirror with a blow of his laathi.  

“They might turn on us now,” a fellow journalist tells me. A returning policeman is a little edgy. “Are you from Delhi?” he asks; and for lack of better words, or perhaps just overwhelmed by emotion, he mutters: “Mohabbat aur jung mein sab jaayaz hai (All’s fair in love ‘n’ war).” 

The day’s protest is over, even if some protestors try to re-assemble and throw stones. We return. Just a mile away, it is quiet on the road that runs along Dal Lake. There are many men making a show of their patience here, fishing rods in hand. Amarnath yatris, back from a pilgrimage to the cavernous Shiva shrine in the higher reaches of Kashmir, are buying corncobs. There is also a visitors’ rush at Nishat Garden, with water gushing as usual from the mouth of a stone lion at its entrance. 

The following day, I meet Irfan at a deserted spot on the outskirts of Srinagar city where he is in hiding. Born in 1987, Irfan’s father is a senior government employee. He grew up in a Kashmir of curfews and military crackdowns. “As children,” he recounts, “we saw security forces killing some of our relatives in cold blood. I was in seventh class when I came out for the first time, burnt an American flag and then pelted a few stones.” In 2007, one of his close friends Muntazir died in police firing in response to stone pelting. He was in class ten. Over the past few years, Irfan has taken part in hundreds of protests. In the meantime, he also completed his degree in computers that he puts to full use. One of the Facebook communities he helped form, named Kal Kharaab Kashur (‘Reckless Kashmiris’), has a police case against it, he claims.  “I want to settle down too, like normal young people, but Kashmir is my first priority,” he avows. 

One of Irfan’s stone-pelting partners is a young boy in the final year of his college. “As kids, we didn’t understand issues,” shrugs the collegian, “But as we grew up we felt that India was like our colonial master.” And then the two get talking about some of the missions they undertook. “You remember how his brain oozed out after the police fired?” “That day I ran away, but he was hit by a teargas shell.” “He has been sent to a jail in Jammu under the PSA and I heard they have broken his limbs.” “That day I jumped into Dal Lake and a rubber bullet hit my leg.” “You should have seen him climbing that police jeep and shattering its glass.” Such snatches of conversation are routine, it seems.

“We will keep on protesting like this,” says Irfan’s friend, “And if some day we realise it is not helping, we will not hesitate to pick up arms like our elder brothers did.” As he plucks out his undershirt to cover his face for a picture, he says, “We don’t want secularism. We don’t want democracy. We want Islamic laws in Kashmir.” Their other friend tries to explain this. “You see, recently the BJP had organised a Bharat Bandh, and their men broke so much property and beat up people. But was a single teargas shell fired at them? Then, why is it that we have to face not only teargas shells but bullets as well?” he asks. “India is in search of peace. We are in search of freedom. Why is it so hard to understand that we have no common ground?” demands another boy. 

One of their friends they call Mandela is in hospital. On 6 July, a police officer fired two bullets at him during an incident of stone pelting. One missed him, while another pierced his chest an inch above his heart and exited from the right. Another bullet killed his friend Abrar who was standing next to him. In the hospital, Mandela, whose real name is Owais—he is 18—lies on a bed, weak and unable to speak. “He cannot tolerate what is happening around him. So he comes out and protests,” says his father, Abdul Hameed. “There is too much anger on the streets. Films are not fiction. They are real. As they show when there is injustice, people pick up stones. And guns, too,” says his cousin, attending to him by his hospital bedside. 

A few miles away from the hospital, Chief Minister Omar Abdullah holds an all-party meet. He has aged in the past few weeks; his hair is more salt than pepper now. People in the Valley are unhappy with him. Journalists are unhappy with him. The police are tired. Ordinary people are tired. 

Amidst the turmoil, Broadway Hotel in Srinagar feels like an oasis of peace. Uniformed gatekeepers open its revolving door, and a few foreign guests discuss the merits of Parmesan cheese. Inside the hotel restaurant, journalists sit in groups, drinking coffee and smoking cigarettes in spite of the ‘No Smoking’ sign, talking of the ‘political void’ and the previous night’s football match. At the bar, two men discuss how tough it is for the poor to earn anything in such difficult times. One of them takes a sip from his glass and then puts it down. There’s a TV screen aglow with highlights of Spain’s World Cup victory. “I think we should call Paul the Octopus. Maybe he can predict when peace will return to Kashmir.”

OLDER COMMENTS FIRST

11 COMMENTS

Permalink

Great writing. Great authenticity of expression. Kudos to you Rahul!

17 July 2010 | Muneeb Habib

Permalink

Superb and unbiased! Atleast this should open some doors of insensitive, cynical and arrogant politicians and people of India. if it doesn't, i pity them all!

17 July 2010 | Azmat

Permalink

Candid reporting at its best. No opinion expressed, not even remotely implied. Events captured in their true bleak moods. One of the best pieces of reporting on Kashmir.

17 July 2010 | rakesh mawa

Permalink

I really appreciate your work. I guess this is the first 100% authentic story I have read. Otherwise all the stories from the Indian media are completely biased.

Great work Rahul and keep it up ....

17 July 2010 | Abbas

Permalink

I like the way how you have tried to create heroes out of misguided youths of Kashmir. Talking in English or wearing Nike is not sign of education. My illiterate maid speaks much better English than most of them. I don’t when we Indians will get over this colonial hangover. What is worrying is that you have tried to portray them as representation of educated Kashmiri youth and we all know that this is not a fact.
But Delhi does need to wake up to face such reckless youth. They remind of the brain washed LTTE youth ready to die for nothing.

17 July 2010 | Amit

Permalink

good job..... sooner or later india has to realise that ...... but i dont think this story will reach out to people

17 July 2010 | muddassir

Permalink

Extremely good report, perhaps the best that has come from this troubled land where political and editorial agendas typically contort all media reports. For this, hats off to Mr Pandita, this is a genuine piece of reporting, and very rare in its insight and honesty.

As for the 'education' level of the characters represented in the report, all one can say is that Bob Dylan fans, whether they wear Nike or New Balance or speak English or Chinese, are guaranteed to be people of a sensitivity which we must respect. How much and how well they have thought about "azadi" we will not know till we have one of them interviewed in depth without censorship (extremely difficult in an ultranationalistic country where people are irrational about worshipping the map of India as a goddess).

19 July 2010 | ramesh Saran

Permalink

It is a fair article to your credit I grant you that, however very typical of the Indian "bleeding hearts" as always to provide a near demonic depiction of the Indian forces' atrocities on the "poor downtrodden" Kashmiries!! Why for one has no mention been made of the self serving activities of the likes of Muftis, Farooqs et al and their impact on this mainly half baked/poorly educated populace I wonder.

The problem with Kashmir I have always felt is Nehru's misguided Harrow Cambridge shaped Victorian sense of justice and fair play rather than a pragmatic solution in 1948 itself. The biggest joke is that these "so called" sophisticated mujaheedens who are so keen to either go and form their homeland or even better merge with the "democratic Pakistan" (!!) should really be allowed to do this. I say this as an ethnic Kashmiri (a theoritical Hindu married to an ethnic English woman and practically being a Brit for all purposes) who despite not being an Indian retains a lot of affection for the "motherland". The sooner Kashmir is asked to fend for itself rather than the continued appeasement of over six decades (including special costitutional rights etc), the better. Even better is for India to singe the wretched place to ground economically and then up the sticks. There is no point in leaving your investment behind! I for one have had enough of these stupid people, who frankly belong in the middle ages. It is only a matter of time before they realise that their so called "Azadi" which that corrupt Shaeeda Madam Bhutto had promised them very opportunistically (much to the delight of the Arundati Roys of this world!) is all but a pipe dream and that once they join their breatheren in Mirpur and Muzzafarabad etc, will they realise that!! So good riddance for sure. And before you ask, trust me I have many close Pakistani friends from my student days in England who are close enough to be my brothers whom I have visited in Pakistan many a time. And most of them agree the futility that is the "partition of India" other than lining up the pockets of the Pakistani army and business houses petriefied at the prospect of having to compete with their former brothers! It is high time the stupid yet savvy (based on this report!) young generation of Kashmir found that out for themselves.

As for Mr Saran's comments above, there is frankly nothing wrong with being "irrational and worship the Indian map etc" as it is those very qualities that made Israel a great nation despite its fervent Zionist agenda. I am a firm anti Hindutva man and have believed in Indian diversity, but on an equal footing for all, not at the cost of any one community. The sad fact is poor Omar Abdullah is too honest for this corrupt and intellectually challanged nay downright mediocre state, the very reason the likes of Mehbooba Mufti etc flourish despite not possessing a modicum of talent nor integrity.

God help my beloved Kashmir and India both! And my prayers for Omar Abdullah too.

26 July 2010 | K Pandit

Permalink

Mr K Pandit's comments, sorry to say, are the equivalent of "I hate THEM, but do not get me wrong, I have many friends in THAT community who are not jerks like the rest of THEM"

So dull, has been heard all before. Like "I am not a Hindutvadi, but tell me, don't you think Hindus are second class citizens in India?"

Bigotry is bigotry, my friend.

11 August 2010 | Ankush Mahdevan

Permalink

Ankush, given that you don't know the first thing about either me or my beliefs, I think your comments are incredulous to say the least. Reading them one might be tempted to accuse me of almost being a reprobate individual!! I therefore have to defend myself and explain my position for your benefit assuming you are indeed capable of understanding it. If you do take the time to look beyond the bloody obvious, you would find that I am mainly berating the pseudo seculars among the Indian (pseudo) intelligentsia. Why must the rest of India suffer because the rag tag Indian government in Delhi finds it difficult to rule its citizens with equaniminity? As for my perceived bigotry, do note that I am the first one to suggest that someone like Modi and his ilk should be severely punished for their misdeeds. But equally suggest that the likes of Muftis and their sons and daughters too ought to be brought to the book for their duplicitous acts over the years. Have you forgotten their hand in glove work of art in 1989/1990??

As for Kashmir's right to secede from the Indian Republic, that remains the natives’ prerogative by all means. Judging by your name however, I presume that you are a South Indian and may possibly be unfamiliar with the nuances of that part of the world, because you would not have missed the obvious flaw in this article. Kashmir is not a homogenized region contrary to the bleatings of the Muftis and Gilanis of this world. Parts of Kashmir were either Hindu dominated or were populated in equal proportions, with a lot of Sufi liberal Muslim population only too happy to cohabit with the Hindu/non Muslim population for generations. But with very generous support from ISI, the militants managed to either drive the Pandits away from the valley in late 80’s and/or shut up the voice of reason supplanting it with bigotry. No one, not one of your pseudo secular Indian press took up their cause, which enabled vile elements such as BJP (India’s answer to our very own BNP in the UK!) to fill that vacuum and make a lot of noise as always without any firm measures during their prolonged rule. That coupled with the wretched Babri fiasco is what has lead to the current denouement! All I wish to know is why the likes of Mr Pandita did not provide a similar platform for the displaced Pandits or give them prolonged media coverage. Several well educated and cultured Kashmiri Pandits were forced to live like animals in those truly horrendous refugee camps, the likes of which were not even seen in Darfur. So before you accuse me of being a bigot, try and appreciate these historical wrongs. But then again, given your input above, you probably wouldn't know bigotry if it hit you in the face!

I firmly remain of the opinion that India's misplaced act of appeasement will not get it any further with these local Talibans and India's best bet remains in calling their bluff for once and for all. Once the local economy is shut down and the fallacy in the belief in Muslim Umma is firmly exposed for once and for all, the same militants will beg the Indians to take them back or alternatively become a Chinese stooge much like their brethrens in Islamabad!! India meanwhile is better off conceding a part of this cesspit if need be and retain its own land and ensure a successful integration thereof with the rest of the country, unlike the treading of eggshells approach it has followed since 1948. But any such politicking must be based on fairness and not subject to the fear mongering much favored by the militants.

I do genuinely feel sorry for the Muslims in the valley, most of whom remain attached to northern India for cultural and economic reasons. Equally the Indian military presence has a thankless task on its hands, perhaps the only thing could be that they become less trigger happy. But then again, it is easier to say that sitting in a nice comfortable room in London/Delhi/Madras/Timbuktu! Do we even know the sort of provocation these militants resort to? It is indeed a great shame that the local leadership is resorting to cheap stunts of pushing the Kashmiri youth to the front line arming them with all sorts of irritating ammunition ranging from stones, eggs to guns! If only Kashmiris could listen to the likes of Wajahat Habibullah and Omar Abdullah, honest men all with very sane heads, the history could be different.

Hope this explains my position suitably to you and anyone else wishing to brand me a bigot! So please first get your facts right, learn to read between the lines (local history and socio eco factors too whilst you are at it!) and don't accuse people of bigotry and bias when you don't know the first thing about them.

18 August 2010 | Kedar Pandit

Permalink

Very relevant story.. wish things were calm and stable in such a beautiful state.

7 September 2010 | Sachin Tendulkar

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

CAPTCHA
NOTE: Please enter letters [case sensitive] in the box provided before you submit your comment. This is to prevent automated spam submissions
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.