Rear Window

Sandipan Deb is an IIT-IIM graduate who wandered into journalism after reading a quote from filmmaker George Lucas — “Everyone’s cage door is open” — and has stayed there (in journalism, not a cage) for the past 19 years. He has written a book on the IITs and is the editor of Open

EMAIL AUTHOR

Too Much Teen Spirit

There are times you just have to wonder. How much freedom do we give our teenagers?
4
Schoolchildren, they would have been in class XI or XII... There were about ten of them, and they were drinking. Not soft drinks, not beer, not Bacardi Breezer. They were having whisky, vodka and tequila.

At a bar in a Delhi suburb one of these evenings, there was a group of kids at a table near where we were sitting. Schoolchildren, they would have been in class XI or XII. They were celebrating the birthday of one of the girls. There were about ten of them, and they were drinking. Not soft drinks, not beer, not Bacardi Breezer. They were having whisky, vodka and tequila. They were knowledgeable enough to even choose the particular brand of tequila they wanted, something, even at my age, I have no idea of.

It was natural that my friend and I were getting increasingly disturbed as the kids went on drinking and the noise mounted. After some time, one of the girls seemed to pass out and was being cradled by one of the boys. At this point, they called one of the waiters, we noticed, for further orders, and some conversation ensued that we couldn’t hear the details of, but the clear import was that the bar was refusing any more drinks to them. Two of the boys got up and one could hear them telling the group that they were going to buy breath fresheners for everybody.

Five minutes later, as I stepped out of the men’s room, one of the girls was puking right there; the women’s room was occupied and she couldn’t hold it back any longer.

In the National Capital Region (or maybe all of India, I don’t know), it is illegal to sell alcohol to anyone under the age of 25. I personally believe this is an unreasonably high age barrier, given that one can vote in general elections at 18. But my personal views hardly count for anything in this situation; the point is that the bar was serving them, fully aware of what was allowed and what was not. And when they refused the group of kids more drinks, it was in fact an act of double cowardice. At a certain point, clearly, the manager of the bar thought that it was getting potentially dangerous, that some of these kids could even be driving home, and there could be a mishap, and the bar’s name could appear in the papers. That would be problematic.

As upper middle class or rich parents, what are the limits we impose on children? Most parents of my generation feel a sense of guilt about not having spent enough time with them while they were growing up, and the easiest (and least time consuming) way to assuage that guilt, to an extent, is to let them blow some money. The only activity that many of us can think of to please the child on a weekend when we have some time for her/him is to go shopping. Spend some cash, the child is satisfied, and our parental duty is done.

Plus, we also carry the burden of another sort of guilt. We would have liked more freedom in our teenage years, as teenagers have wanted throughout human history. And most of us feel that our parents could have been a bit more lenient towards us. Now you are a parent, and you like to believe you are ‘liberal’, ‘progressive’, and other such terms that have become de rigueur for people of your demographics. So you don’t want to chain your child down, and you don’t know how long and elastic the chain should be, if it exists at all. And if you are too busy with your career and other worldly matters, you just hand the brat some money and get him out of your hair. And, especially in North India, you believe that if the brat does get into any trouble, you can easily pull some strings and, well, achieve clearance and closure.

I feared for these kids that I saw in the bar. And I know I should have gone up to the manager and told him what I thought of this. I did not. By evening, our urban life fatigues us, and that apathy which lies just below our skin kicks in, in full force. And I realised that that’s what’s wrong with those kids’ parents. And with us as parents.

OLDER COMMENTS FIRST

4 COMMENTS

Permalink

While I sympathize with your fears as a parent, I think that this, right here, is the problem with parents in India today. I'm 15 and I go to a private school in New Delhi, and I do some things which maybe, my parents may not be "proud of". I think the basic fact that all parents need to accept is that, hey, kids ARE going to dwindle with drugs, alcohol, sex and eating disorders. It's how much YOU make it a taboo subject that determines how safe they'll be while they're at it.

It's a teenage terminology to do the exact opposite of what we're told to do. If you say "holy hell, sex. Let's just not talk about it, and if I find you ever indulging in it before you're 20, I will stab you in your sleep", they'll go out and do it just to spite you and to see what the fuss is all about.
The point I'm trying to make is that YOU as parents have to make it, not as issue of abstinence but of safe sex, not of being a tea totaler but letting them have a few drinks with you around so they know how to control themselves.

What you guys have to accept is that this is just what kids do; experiment. And you've to give them the freedom to do that.

14 March 2010 | Anon

Permalink

Mr. Deb,

I read one of your previous articles about how children of my generation will find it hard to face the problems of our future lives because we aren't magical and don't have wands. After reading this particular article, it seems to me that you've taken it up in your stride to downplay my generation and their behavior's and habit's.

Sure kids smoke, do drugs, and drink before it's legal. I'm not disagreeing with you on that. But don't tell me that this is something new. People in YOUR generation have done that as well. My own Dad, for example. He told me during a conversation that he drank before he should have, and he told me that he's not proud of it. But he also told me that he would do it all over again if he had a choice because otherwise he would have never know what all the fuss was about. My friends parents have done drugs as well, and they told us that they were just experimenting. Only difference is that they tried it when they were around 17-18 years old, not 16.

Times change, people change. And so do view points. What was considered normal for an 18 year old then, is considered normal for a 16 year old now. In India, people can drive once the turn 18. But in America they can do so once they turn 16. You see the difference don't you? The superpower has come to terms with change. In England people can drink once they turn 18, In India they have to wait till their 25. The phrase "God save the Queen!" comes to mind. Parents here need to accept the fact that their kids are going to experiment. The will grow up. They will face difficulties. And they know that, But despite having that knowledge they will still go ahead and do what they "shouldn't".

It's in the nature of teenagers to try new things. If they don't, they may never learn what's right and what's wrong. Sometimes you have got to have a hands on experience. The kids that you saw were clearly going over board, but then again it would be weird if they didn't. They were presented with something that had been denied to them all along and so they're bound to go over the top.

The resultant being vomit. And I really don't see how that is so bad. At least this way the girl will know her limit.

I'm certain you would have done something "wild" in you're teenage years, obviously not drinking/smoking/OD-ing/having sex. Because you're good. You know when to say when. You're not curious. You don't want any answers. You will sit at home like a good little boy and work hard so that one day you can become a writer for OPEN and publish articles on things you have no idea about because you have never experienced it.

But you've done something wild. Or so I hope. For you and you're kids.

Regards,
Naina

PS: I understand that you are concerned as a parent, but you need to give the youth the space the need to spread their wings and fly. Or you could just give them space to do what they want, and believe you me, eventually they WILL stop. Please do mail me on your opinion concerning this matter.

14 March 2010 | Naina

Permalink

I dont agree with Naina here.
I am her generation (22 years old).
I am a graphic designer in London.
I have seen 'life' with just beer.
What deb is describing is bit too much i think especially at 16 - 18.
There has to be some limit.
Ask me why, I will tell you.

Amey

16 March 2010 | Amey

Permalink

Either you believe alcohol is ok or you do not. If you do, then it is young people who are at less danger from it than old people. Ask your doctor

19 March 2010 | Rajneesh

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
NOTE: Please enter letters [case sensitive] in the box provided before you submit your comment. This is to prevent automated spam submissions
4 + 2 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.